
by Alan Dershowitz
Excerpts from an address to the international Chabad Lubavitch Shluchim Convention at the NY City Hilton, November 27, 2005
Wow, what a gathering. The energy, the love, the yiddishkeit in this room is beyond belief. Whenever I hear people worried about the diminution of Judaism, I wish they could be here to experience this.
Thirty five years ago I had the merit to meet the great Rebbe- one of the great honors and educational experiences of my life. We then corresponded and I continued to learn. I had the chutzpah to once write him a letter, saying how come for your 80th birthday you decided among those you wanted to honor was Senator Jesse Helms. At the time Senator Jesse Helms was not a friend of the Jewish people, nor a friend of Israel. The Rebbe wrote me back saying: you honor not only to influence the past, but to influence the future. He said: watch and see whether or not our decision was correct. Within a year of that honor Jesse Helms had become one of the strongest supporters of Israel in the Senate and as chairman of the Foreign Relations committee one of its most important. You live and you learn. I learned a great deal from many of the Shluchim that I met over the years.
I used to travel regularly to the former Soviet Union, to Poland, to the Ukraine, to Latvia, to Lithuania, and I dont remember a single flight that I was on that there wasnt at least a single Shliach. We were there on separate business; I was defending Jews from prosecution, I was in the court on their behalf, people like Nathan Sharansky, and they were just saving Jews; and they were creating the future of Judaism in what they had complete confidence would be a Russia free of communism and able to respect the rights of so many Jews who lived there under oppression. It was remarkable to see Shluchim to those obscure parts of the world.
When it was announced that I would be speaking here tonight I got an interesting call from New York Magazine asking: why; why are you, a civil rights and civil liberties lawyer speaking for Chabad? You dont agree with all their policies. Somehow the reporter also knew that my own family is a misnaged family.
But we always had a very warm spot in our hearts for Chabad. My mother always had a love for Chabad. Not so long ago, she needed heart surgery. She went to an eminent cardiologist who had in fact treated the Rebbe, and he also treated the Pope. To show what a great doctor he was he showed my mother the two pictures on the wall, there was the pope and there was the Rebbe. The popes picture was hanging higher than the Rebbes. When the doctor left to treat another patient my mother had switched the pictures. My mother who taught me the meaning of chutzpah said to Dr. Cohen: Your name is Cohen, you are a Jew, and the Rebbe gets top billing in this office.
So when New York magazine asked me why? the implication was if you dont agree with everything, you must agree with nothing. I explained to the reporter that Ive learned from Chabad to emphasize points of agreement, rather than points of disagreement, to look at the positive. Chabad doesnt require agreement; Chabad simply opens itself up to Jews without regard to their theology, to their perspective, to their attitudes towards life. There are no questions asked, and Chabad provides a wonderful model for the entire Jewish community.
I think of what happened a few years ago when this young Rabbi came to see me and said were thinking about opening a Chabad at Harvard, my idea was: Siberia, thats nothing, central Africa thats a breeze; but Chabad at Harvard? Impossible. Kids come to Harvard to rebel against their parents, to rebel against religion, to look for other ways, to look for more liberal attitudes. Could Chabad succeed at Harvard? As soon as I met Hirshy and Elkie it was clear that it would succeed.
And they had a secret. Their secret was dont ask Harvard students to do anything inconsistent with their own secular philosophy, emphasize those activities in which men and women can celebrate Chanukah together by lighting a Menorah, celebrate Purim, celebrate sitting in the sukkah together. It worked so marvelously, because Elkie and Hirshy emphasize what the Jews of Harvard shared in common, the 90% that we agree on rather than the 10% that we dont agree on.
That to me is so critical because the Jewish community as a whole always specializes in the 10%. How can we disagree; what do we have that differentiates us; what can we argue about? The old story of the Jew who was on a desert island, after 15 years he had built two shuls, the one I go to and the one I wouldnt go near; or the Israeli who had been found on the island and after 15 years he had created 15 political parties and published 12 newspapers, thats the tradition of Jews arguing about everything. Chabad says no, lets focus on the 90% that we agree and deemphasize the 10%, the 10% we can talk about, we dont have to change our philosophy. It is simply a question of emphasis and I think thats the great success of Harvards Chabad. 400 people a few weeks ago attended a regular Shabbat at Harvard Law School, 400 Harvard law students. They were coming for the spirituality that Chabad offers them and it was a great success.
We are seeing a revolution in American university education stimulated by Chabad. A major revolution!
What I learned from Chabad, I now take on the road. I speak on college campuses defending Israel and speaking about Jewish values and I learned the same secret., I dont start by saying Prime Minister Sharon wants to do this, I disagree; or the Labor party wants to do this, I disagree. Thats the way most Jewish speakers start their speeches. I talk about the 90%, I talk about what is it that we all agree about, what we support and the enemies of Israel oppose, lets resolve those issues first then we can resolve; If we ever can the 10% that separates us.
I want to mention the areas of agreement on which there is broad consensus among the Jewish people:
1. The right of Israel to exist and thrive as a Jewish state. Who can disagree with that in the Jewish community?
2. The right of Israel to defend itself, to defend its citizens. To have assured boundaries and to be free from the terror of terrorism.
3. The right of Israel to be treated equally and not subjected to a double standard on university campuses, at the United Nations, in the European community and everyplace in the world today.
4. The right of Israel not to be demonized and defamed on college campuses the way it happens so often today, whether it be at Berkeley or Columbia or at so many other major universities in America.
5. The right of Jews to live anywhere in the world. No part of the world should ever be Judenrein free of Jews. The right of Jews to practice Judaism and to be educated Jewishly, and to be treated equally by the government in every country which they live.
6. Equally important as the right to be treated equally is the right of Jews to retain their separate identity and to be different if they choose to, without any obligations to melt or to assimilate into anyone elses culture.
7. a negative right, a very important one, one that has been very important to Jewish history. The right of every Jew to leave any country that does not treat us with dignity, with equality and with fairness.
8. The right of both Israel and Judaism, not only to survive, but to thrive and to increase kein yirbu.
9. Finally, a right that we all share, a right to hope someday for a better world.
These are the ten points of agreement that I speak about on campuses. I dont get into the debates about specific policies in Israel with which one can agree or disagree. Two nights from now I am debating Noam Chomsky, probably the most influential intellectual and the greatest enemy of Israel today, and I am debating him in Harvards Kennedy school. I will focus on these ten points of agreement and I hope I can persuade people when they agree with these ten points to see that Israels rights are being diminished and the rights of Jews are being threatened.
Now when Jews face external threats as too often we have, we do join together and focus on what is common and what is agreeable. G-d forbid when we had the Holocaust, when Israel was threatened existentially in 1967 and 1973, we tended to come together and emphasize the agreements but I make a point that it is equally important for Jews to emphasize their commonality even when there is no crisis on the horizon. Now, Jews are never without a crisis, we always fight the twin crises, on the one hand of external threats which continue. Anti-Semitism is growing in many parts of the world today, so we face external threats, we face external threats to Israel, we often face internal threats, threats of assimilation, intermarriage, threats of what I call in my book the vanishing American Jew and I think Chabad has learned how to respond both to the external and to the internal and spiritual.
A few years ago I was asked to speak at Columbia University. Student groups called me and said the Jewish community is very divided, we have nothing in common that we share. We need you to come to Columbia to unify us. I said I would be happy to do it but I couldnt do it for the next month because I was busy with classes so I told them to call me in about a month. In about a month the same woman called me and said Professor Dershowitz, we dont need you; somebody better has come to Columbia and has really united the Jewish community. I was a little insulted, I said who? and she said Louis Farrakhan. By coming to Columbia and preaching anti- Semitism Farrakhan had united the Jewish people, that kind of stimulus unification we can do without. Judaism adapts to crisis, we know how well it does when it faces external threats; the real test of Judaism is how it deals with its internal crises and how it deals with problems that cannot be blamed outside of the Jewish community. I call this the tzures theory of Jewish survival, the theory that says Jews need tzures to survive. We dont want tzures, we dont want to be attacked and nonetheless we want to survive and thrive.
Chabad has taught us how to have Judaism without the "Oy," but with the Joy; and introducing the joy instead of the "oy." Kohelet has a wonderful statement that says Lechol Zman to everything there is a season, and Chabad has figured out how to be not only responsive but proactive as to every season of Jewish life. Its there in times of difficulty, saving people in the storms, in times of crisis. We often neglect what Chabad does to bring the joy, during relative calm that we sometimes experience.
Somewhere in the world there is always a Jew in crisis and somewhere in the world there are always Jews at peace and Chabad has figured out a way of dealing with both in a very admirable and positive way.
I want to end this greeting with a phrase. When I went to the Soviet Union for the first time in the early 70s it was virtually a crime to say it, people had to say it in the secrecy of their homes, people had to worry when they said it. No longer is that the case.
Am Yisrael Chai! The Jewish people lives. We all acknowledge our debt to Chabad for keeping it alive, for never giving up hope, for focusing proactively on the young as well as the aged.
The enemies of Israel focus on college campuses. Why do they focus on college campuses? Obvious. They focus on college campuses because they know tomorrows leaders are today studying, and if they can poison the minds at the Sorbonne, at Oxford, at Cambridge, at Harvard, at Berkeley, at Princeton, at Yale, wherever people today study. If they can poison the minds of young Jews and non-Jews, away from Israel and toward a rigidly anti-Israeli point of view, they hope that in 15-20 years or 25 years, when these students become the leaders of their countries they will have the knee-jerk anti-Israel attitudes we see in so many places.
Thats why Chabads presence on college campuses today is absolutely crucial. Not only to respond but to inoculate; to make young people proud of being Jewish; to make young people proud that they support Israel; to make young people understand that the support of Israel is one of the great human rights issues of the 21st century.
One of great issues of human rights today is whether Israels willingness to defend itself, to demand secure boundaries and to protect its citizens, will become yet another excuse in the millennial-long fight to prevent anti-Semitism from engulfing the world. The Jews are the canary in the mine shaft. Whenever Jews have been subject to anti-Semitism, they are the first, but they are never the last.
Thats why the fight for the minds, the hearts, and souls of college students today is so important. And thats why we must extend a collective yasher koach to the Chabad Shluchim at Penn, at Connecticut, at Princeton etc.
We cannot rest until there is at least one Chabad shliach on every major college campus in the world. Until every Jewish student feels pride in saying to other Jews and to non-Jews on the campus: Am Yisrael Chai!